Alexander Dunn helps solve centuries-long mathematical mystery

Alexander Dunn

Where this story truly begins is difficult to say.

It could be somewhere in the early nineteenth century, when mathematician Ernst Eduard Kummer began experimenting with cubic Gauss sums, leading him to record a conjecture that would remain open for more than 150 years. Or perhaps this story picks up in the 1950s, when physicist Hedvig Selberg programmed a vacuum-tube computer to calculate around 600 sums—twice—to help John von Neumann and Herman Goldstine test Kummer’s theory. One might also argue that this story’s true origins go back to the University of Cambridge, where Samuel J. Patterson, hooked on this mystery surrounding cubic Gauss sums, replaced Kummer’s conjecture with his own. But for Alexander Dunn (PhD, 2020, mathematics) and his mentor Maksym Radziwiłł, the story began in a parking lot in Pasedena, California.

According to an article in Quanta magazine, Dunn and Radziwiłł spent months trying to find an answer that had eluded mathematicians for ages: if you were to plot all the infinitely possible cubic Gauss sums, how evenly would they be distributed?

Kummer’s 1846 conjecture suggested the pattern would not be random. Though he was only able to calculate 45 sums in total, he found they were distributed in an odd, but orderly way, clustering around a value of 1: most results fell between 1/2 and 1; fewer between –1/2 and 1/2; and even fewer between –1 and –1/2. When Selberg, Goldstein, and von Neumann ran their calculations, they discovered that as the primes increased, the sums appeared to be distributed more randomly. Though they hadn’t necessarily disproven Kummer’s theory, they certainly hadn’t proven it. This curiosity led number theorists to study the Kummer conjecture regarding cubic Gauss sums with a particular intensity for the next several decades. Though advances on the problem were made, it remained open. However, in 1978, Samuel Patterson made revised conjecture. Patterson speculated that the sum of all the cubic Gauss sums for primes less than N is roughly N5/6.  His conjecture implied that cubic Gauss sums behave like sums of random numbers, but that they are influenced by a weak bias towards positive values. In other words, it would explain the conflicting observations of Kummer and the IAS researchers.

Patterson refined his conjecture further in 1979 with Roger Heath-Brown, who would later develop a tool called the large cubic sieve that could relate the sum of cubic Gauss sums to a different sum, making their values easier to infer. Though his use of the cubic large sieve did not definitively prove Patterson’s initial conjecture, it provided supporting evidence. At the time, Heath-Brown thought the sieve could be improved. In a paper he published in 2000, he noted what he thought would be the best formula for the sieve, believing it to be a superior version that could one-day help prove Patterson’s conjecture.  

As it turned out, Heath-Brown’s work would ultimately lead mathematicians to prove Patterson’s conjecture, but not in the way he imagined. After much laborious and complicated work, Dunn and Radziwiłł discovered the new formula posited by Heath-Brown—one that had been largely accepted by modern number theorists—wasn’t correct.

Determining that the large cubic sieve could not be improved helped Dunn and Radziwiłł approach the task from a different angle, and in the end, they triumphed. After 175 years, the question Kummer had posed to the mathematical community finally had an answer: Patterson’s conjecture had been right, and Dunn and Radziwiłł had proven it. Part of the sieve Heath-Brown had initially developed still proved invaluable to Dunn and Radzwiłł; in the paper they posted on September 15, 2021, they included the following note: “An important ingredient in our proof is a dispersion estimate for cubic Gauss sums. It can be interpreted as a cubic large sieve with correction by a non-trivial asymptotic main term.”

Dunn points out that his work isn’t the first time that a UIUC affiliate has gotten involved with the mystery surrounding the Kummer conjecture. Mathematical Reviews® is a journal published by the American Mathematical Society (AMS) that provides information on peer-reviewed articles and books, and it was Professor Emeritus Bruce Berndt who wrote the “math review” of Patterson’s 1978 paper. One line from Berndt review reads “One aim of the present paper is to bring Kummer’s conjecture back to respectability and to enunciate a more precise version of this conjecture.” Dunn and Radziwiłł’s work has done just that.

Though Dunn and Radziwiłł’s proof is conditional on the generalized Riemann hypothesis, an infamously open conjecture in mathematics, Leila Sloman explains in her piece for Quanta Magazine that many mathematicians agree that a conditional result is still a huge triumph. When the news of Dunn and Radziwiłł’s accomplishment rolled into the Department of Mathematics at Illinois, the number theory research group rejoiced.

“This is a tour de force in analytic number theory,” says Scott Ahlgren, professor of mathematics at Illinois and Dunn’s former advisor. “It proves an old and beautiful conjecture and sheds new light on the large sieve (one of the fundamental tools of analytic number theory). And it seems certain that the methods of this paper will find many future applications.”

Dunn credits his education from the Illinois Department of Mathematics as crucial to his success: I would like to thank the number theory group at UIUC for the training and support I received [while earning] my PhD. In particular, I would like to acknowledge my advisors Scott Ahlgren and Alexandru Zaharescu. Without the opportunity to study at UIUC, I wouldn't have been prepared to tackle research problems like this one.”

Directory

berndtBruce
Berndt
palmoreJulian
Palmore
wendychoWendy
Cho
kdarmstrKevin
Armstrong
muncastRobert
Muncaster
bradlowSteven
Bradlow
mullen1Tony
Mullen
lshkhmb2Almuthana
Alshaikhmubarak
mblocherMarci
Blocher
rmccrthyRandy
McCarthy
ajs167A.J.
Schmidt
jathreyaJayadev
Athreya
n-bostonNigel
Boston
glazebroJames
Glazebrook
dhundertDirk
Hundertmark
lakelandGrant
Lakeland
marcutIoan-Tiberiu
Marcut
skokanJozef
Skokan
jmsJohn
Sullivan
wolframStephen
Wolfram
teandersThomas
Anderson
cbreezeCaitie
Bruning
butsonKerry
Butson
pballenPatrick
Allen
msbormanMatthew
Borman
psdeyPartha
Dey
csdodd2Christopher
Dodd
jbhellerJeremiah
Heller
jpascaleJames
Pascaleff
vesnaVesna
Stojanoska
curridPeggy
Currid
kmortensKaren
Mortensen
carpentBruce
Carpenter
abcAlison
Champion
amrphyAnu
Murphy
bergvMaarten
Bergvelt
nmdNathan
Dunfield
hiraniAnil
Hirani
verahurVera Mikyoung
Hur
ekermanEly
Kerman
ekirrEduard-Wilhelm
Kirr
xcliXiaochun
Li
zraptiZoi
Rapti
tzirakisNikolaos
Tzirakis
rdevilleLee
DeVille
palbinPierre
Albin
kkirkpatKay
Kirkpatrick
rfengRunhuan
Feng
jrmcneilJennifer
McNeilly
aredAlison
Reddy
gdwatsonDave
Watson
warnowTandy
Warnow
murphyrfBob
Murphy
danbeDaniel
Berwick-Evans
amhoffApril
Hoffmeister
amanfroiAldo
Manfroi
kwhittleKim
Whittlesey
rguzma1Rosemary
Guzman
burnerBecky
Burner
ruilojaRui Loja
Fernandes
raburt2Roger
Burt
clchris2Cassie
Christenson
ellis23Matthew
Ellis
longhao2Longhao
Jin
jkim208Timmy
Kim
wykim2Woo Yul
Kim
hannamk2Hanna
Kristensen
emilyss2Emily
Shinkle
yuchens4Yuchen
Sun
etatum2Elizabeth
Tatum
qiangwu2Qiang
Wu
shuyux2Shuyu
Xiao
philippePhilippe
Di Francesco
abdiker2Samal
Abdikerimova
iahmed8Iftikhar
Ahmed
balderr2William
Balderrama
nbhard4Neer
Bhardwaj
hburso2Hannah
Burson
dcarmod2Daniel
Carmody
chebaoYusuf
Chebao
donepud2Ravi
Donepudi
ajdunn2Alexander
Dunn
fassina2Martino
Fassina
ecfield2Elizabeth
Field
cgartla2Chris
Gartland
atb2Alexi
Block Gorman
gramcko2Mary
Gramcko-Tursi
xhan25Xiaolong
Han
terence2Terence
Harris
eheath3Emily
Heath
jhuan105Jesse
Huang
dihli2Dakota
Ihli
eakapla2Elliot
Kaplan
vkarve2Vaibhav
Karve
dkielty2Derek
Kielty
hkim404Heejoung
Kim
klajbor2Stef
Klajbor-Goderich
linali2Lina
Li
sli205Shixuan
Li
hli102Haojian
Li
xiaoli17Xiao
Li
clinden2Christopher
Linden
wlinz2William
Linz
xliu150Xujun
Liu
cliu105Chongda
Liu
loa2Christopher
Loa
mlin39Mingyan
Lin
sungwoo2Sungwoo
Nam
dn2Dana
Neidinger
coneill4Ciaran
O'Neill
okano2Tsutomu
Okano
spark287Shinhae
Park
petrckv2Sarka
Petrickova
jtpruit2Joseph
Pruitt
pynncoa2Nigel
Pynn-Coates
hquan4Hadrian
Quan
rennie2Robert
Rennie
cer2Colleen
Robichaux
romanga2Fernando
Roman-Garcia
sadovea2Vlad
Sadoveanu
brians2Brian
Shin
thiry2Simone
Sisneros-Thiry
nwang12Nuoya
Wang
hpwang2Hsin-Po
Wang
jjwen2Joshua
Wen
swester3Samuel
Wester
bwwrigh2Benjamin
Wright
yujiy2Yuji
Yang
yzhng172Yuxuan
Zhang
lzhao35Lutian
Zhao
heyizhu2Heyi
Zhu
zirlin2Dara
Zirlin
fbocaFlorin
Boca
bronskiJared
Bronski
jpdaJohn
D'Angelo
s-duttaSankar
Dutta
duursmaIwan
Duursma
berdoganM.
Erdogan
ford126Kevin
Ford
whaboushWilliam
Haboush
aimoAimo
Hinkkanen
ivanovSergei
Ivanov
mjungeMarius
Junge
kapovichIlya
Kapovich
katzsSheldon
Katz
kostochkAlexandr
Kostochka
laugesenRichard
Laugesen
cleinChris
Leininger
lermanEugene
Lerman
mineyevIgor
Mineyev
inikIgor
Nikolaev
reznickBruce
Reznick
z-ruanZhong-Jin
Ruan
schenckHal
Schenck
rsongRenming
Song
r-sowersRichard
Sowers
tumanovAlexander
Tumanov
vddriesLou van den
Dries
jmwuJang-Mei
Wu
ayongAlexander
Yong
zaharescAlexandru
Zaharescu
vzhVadim
Zharnitsky
sahlgrenScott
Ahlgren
mandoMatthew
Ando
tysonJeremy
Tyson
jobalJozsef
Balogh
ssoleckiSlawomir
Solecki
rezkCharles
Rezk
rinatRinat
Kedem
tolmanSusan
Tolman
sbaStephanie
Alexander
ababakhaArarat
Babakhanian
idbergI
Berg
berksonEarl
Berkson
pbraunfePeter
Braunfeld
craggsRobert
Craggs
ecdadeEverett
Dade
hdiamondHarold
Diamond
rmfossumRobert
Fossum
gfrancisGeorge
Francis
z-furediZoltan
Furedi
pgriffitPhillip
Griffith
w-hakenWolfgang
Haken
w-hensonC.
Henson
ajhA
Hildebrand
gjanuszGerald
Janusz
cjockuscCarl
Jockusch
rpkaufmaRobert
Kaufman
ploebPeter
Loeb
mccullohLeon
McCulloh
mclindenLynn
McLinden
j-miles3Joseph
Miles
e-peckEmily
Peck
peressinAnthony
Peressini
pillayAnand
Pillay
eportnoyEsther
Portnoy
dsrobinsDerek
Robinson
rosnblttJoseph
Rosenblatt
stolarskKenneth
Stolarsky
tondeurPhilippe
Tondeur
ullomStephen
Ullom
weichselPaul
Weichsel
ecwElliot
Weinberg
dwestDouglas
West
shjSheldon
Jacobson
ymbYuliy
Baryshnikov
lanaveGabriele
La Nave
denkaDenka
Kutzarova
oikhbergTimur
Oikhberg
schoenroZac
Schoenrock
annbyersAnn
Byers
drennanMark
Drennan
aflowersAmber
Holmes
anygard2Andrew
Nygard
fgwhelpFaisal
Whelpley
lfolwa2Lena
Folwaczny
svbutlerSvetlana
Butler
sbaluyotSiegfred
Baluyot
rmonkeRichard
Monke
na17Nachiketa
Adhikari
kleismanKatelyn
Leisman
mlavrovMikhail
Lavrov
jaffe4Grace
Jaffe
vb8Venkata Sai Narayana
Bavisetty
fclemen2Felix
Clemen
tcdrake2Timothy
Drake
oscareg2Oscar
González
zhixing5Zhixing
Guo
nyhuynh2Chi
Huynh
ranj2Ran
Ji
kexinj2Kexin
Jin
jtkelm2Justin
Kelm
abhrak2Abhra
Kundu
pedrom2Pedro
Mendes De Araujo
marissa9Marissa
Miller
adriana6Adriana
Morales Miranda
anguye76Anh Tuong
Nguyen
cschulz3Christian
Schulz
siskaki2Maria
Siskaki
weihang3Weihang
Wang
npw2Nikolas
Wojtalewicz
shukunw2Shukun
Wu
peixuew2Peixue
Wu
yadav7Harshit
Yadav
zomback2Jenna
Zomback
camruddCameron
Rudd
chaeryn2Chaeryn
Lee
mgj3Gayana
Jayasinghe
drgDaniel
Grayson
childrssMatthew
Childress
lanwang2Lan
Wang
ccui9Chaoyue
Cui
mf12Timmy
Feng
dil4Di
Liu
omusleh2Omar
Musleh
jiajiey3Jiajie
Yang
xinran4Xinran
Yu
dculverDominic
Culver
mycyk1Steven
Mycyk
kahome2Kelvin
Kahome
ebossen2Erin
Madden
antonio9Antonio
Ruiz
cheboluSunil
Chebolu
gordon3Yevgeniy
Gordon
dlindersDaniel
Linders
dlutzerDavid
Lutzer
h-portaHoracio
Porta
vskaush2Vivek
Kaushik
ptkramerPaul
Kramer
tjtuckerTheresa
Tucker
songjJun
Song
ecnEeltje
Nijholt
yevgenyaYevgenya
Movshovich
eionmb2Eion
Blanchard
wittrigAaron
Wittrig
pmotakisPavlos
Motakis
ruiyuanRuiyuan
Chen
basilio3Brannon
Basilio
ekc3Efstathios Konstantinos
Chrontsios Garitsis
rdicks2Robert
Dicks
rig2Ramon Ivan
Garcia Alvarez
fultonj2Fulton
Jackson
yifanj6Yifan
Jing
nekim2Hanna
Kim
kesavsk2Kesav
Krishnan
phuong2Phuong (Sophie)
Le
jdm7Joseph
Malionek
daniam2Dania
Morales
mnahvi2Mina
Nahvi
jungsoo3Jung Soo
Park
souktik2Souktik
Roy
ajschmd2James
Schmidt
gterlov2Grigory
Terlov
vhv3Vincent
Villalobos
nyamzon2Nicole
Yamzon
lukaz2Luka
Zwaan
zonghao2Zonghao
Yang
nargiz2Nargiz
Alekberova
ckb4Chenna Krishna Reddy
Bhumi Reddy
carnick2Henry
Carnick
supasin2Supasin
Chalermpoonsup
qndao2Quang
Dao
xiying2Xiying
Du
agovind2Advith
Govindarajan
ahore2Ankush
Hore
zji7Zhenghan
Ji
linshan3Linshan
Jiang
ptjones2Paul
Jones
kim705Chloe
Kim
yunlao2Yun
Lao
rohansl2Rohan
Limaye
biwenl2Biwen
Ling
cfma2Chenfei
Ma
ycmeng2Ying-Chia
Meng
nmertia2Nikhil
Mertia
gidono2Gidon
Orelowitz
ppadhye2Prathamesh
Padhye
liangq3Liang
Qiao
bsehgal2Bhanu
Sehgal
dseol3Bill
Seol
aerimsi2Aerim
Si
navjot2Navjot
Singh
osoyoye2Olushola
Soyoye
hanwei3Han
Wei
daxu2Da
Xu
fudixu2Fudi
Xu
jchuangJer-Chin
Chuang
adoronAdam
Dor On
shiangShiang
Tang
aronahAron
Heleodoro
pkcolePaa Kow
Cole
ereddenEmily
Lange
sdwStaci
Walker
brockem2Brock
Martin
sairaa2Saira
Ahmed
altizio2David
Altizio
igoraa2Igor
Albuquerque Araujo
rachelb8Rachel
Barnett
cbento1Christopher
Benton
bivziuk2Vladyslav
Bivziuk
cbblake2Charlotte
Blake
ryanjb4Ryan
Britton
jingbin2Jingbin
Cao
shaowen4Shaowen
Chang
hungchu2Hung
Chu
rdavino2Rocco
Davino
shuyued2Shuyue
Deng
tdobbs2Theresa
Dobbs
qiuling2Qiuling
Fan
mfarris3Madie
Farris
sgao23Shiliang
Gao
jcgrady2Connor
Grady
doronlg2Doron
Grossman-Naples
yucongg2Yucong
Guo
zah2Zachary
Halladay
sharma65Scott
Harman
ch47Changyue
Hu
mudakir2Mudakir
Hussien
shanj4Shan
Jiang
ark9Akash Reddy
Kakularam
wonwook2Wonwoo
Kang
sk61Seongyoon
Kim
rak5Bob
Krueger
amank3Aman
Kumar
arlasko2Aubrey
Laskowski
botingl2Boting
Li
churui2Churui
Li
xli145Xiaotian
Li
yuxuanl9Yuxuan
Li
bingyan2Bingyan
Liu
ruiqil6Ruiqi
Liu
ryanm12Ryan
McConnell
mccourt4Grace
McCourt
pacun2Alexander
Pacun
dadongp2Dadong
Peng
pourmot2Saaber
Pourmotabbed
sambits2Sambit
Senapati
ruiqis3Ruiqi
Sha
sheyka2Jonathan
Sheyka
sarah97Sarah
Simpson
ksingh15Kamalpreet
Singh
lecheng3Lecheng
Su
qihangs2Qihang
Sun
jgtan2Johnson
Tan
samuelt6Sam
Thompson
kvasu2Karthik
Vasu
yianwan2Yian
Wan
jingzhi7Jingzhi
Wang
xisuw2Xisu
Wang
fanxin2Fanxin
Wu
jingwu8Jing
Wu
xi8Yuxiang
Xi
yongxie2Yong
Xie (谢永)
jx6Jingwei
Xu
zijingy2Zijing
Ye
ty19Tianyang
Yi
lzhang18Linfeng
Zhang
zixuan8Zixuan
Zou
jelliot2Jason
Elliot
smprtnEric
Samperton
lplaczekLaura
Placzek
aabarronAlexander
Barron
obeckOlivia
Beckwith
senglishSean
English
daesungkDaesung
Kim
sadanandChandrika
Sadanand
zhaouiucZhao
Yang
acontr25Andy
Contreras
rhyxian2Rhyxian
Lim
mliu48Mianfeng
Liu
eitanm2Eitan
Margalit
solberg4Henry
Solberg
lilangw2Lilang
Wang
sw24Songfeng
Wu
mx12Minghao
Xu
esizovaElizaveta
Sizova
zhizhenzZhizhen
Zhao
burgesskKaitlin
Burgess
kelleyeElizabeth
Kelley
yichen23Jason
Liu
yichen23Jason
Liu
xjing4Xiaochen
Jing
atdavisAaron
Davis
atdavisAaron
Davis
leditzkyFelix
Leditzky
astelzerAda
Stelzer
astelzerAda
Stelzer
skoehneShelby
Koehne
jmhardinJohn
Hardin
Related Topics